Old Nags Head Place Rentals

When staying in Old Nags Head Place community, guests benefit from being located right in the heart of Nags Head while still in a quiet neighborhood. Old Nags Head Place’s greatest asset is its relaxing neighborhood setting that is just a short walk from the beach. Guests of Old Nags Head Place have the privilege of using the Curlew St. beach access walkway that runs right through the community as well as the Hollowell St. beach access which sits on the southern border of the community. In addition to Old Nags Head Place’s close vicinity to the beach, the community is also situated next to a couple of fantastic Outer Banks restaurants. These restaurants, which are less than a mile from the community, include The Pier House Restaurant on Nags Head Pier and Tortugas Lie.

Amenities:

Short Distance to Beach Accesses, Quiet Neighborhood, and Close Proximity to Restaurants


Properties Available 19 properties available
Ideally situated in the heart of Nags Head, this terrific vacation home offers the perfect mix of amenities, location, style and comfort. Located in Old Nags Head Place the Todd House offers the luxury of having your own Private Swimming Pool, Hot Tub and a short walk to the Beach (approximately 250 yards. to Hollowell Street Beach access). Jockey’
829 | The Todd House
Home Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half bath
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.8
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.5 (6)
Extensive landscaping and expansion of the pool patio area provides exceptional outdoor living areas for families to enjoy. This is an outstanding vacation home that provides everything your family could want while visiting the OBX! "Capt. Charlie's" is an exceptional vacation home located in Old Nags Head Place, an upscale development nestled in
408 | Capt. Charlie's
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.6 (32)
This fantastic home promises to provide everything your family could want in a vacation destination. It boasts a spacious floor plan, very well-equipped kitchen, hardwood floors, Ocean Views, Rec. Room w/Pool Table, Elevator serving all levels. The Beach Access is located at Bainbridge Street which is only a 3 minute walk away (approximately 340 f
819 | Tiresum
Home Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 6 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half bath
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.7
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.6 (34)
For 2026: Newly expanded, fenced rear yard that is nicely landscaped and ideal for your family and pets. This lovely Beach home offers terrific Outer Banks vacationing for your family, friends, & canine companions. Beautifully decorated & very well-equipped, Sundance provides all the amenities for your comfort including a Private Swimm
671 | Sundance
Home Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.2 (32)
Outstanding design and beautiful décor combine to make this vacation home a wonderful choice for your family’s Outer Banks retreat. Located in the desirable "Old Nags Head Place" community, this home is spacious, fully equipped, and offers something for every member of your group. Take a dip in your own Private Swimming Pool or entertain in the Rec
116 | Seaspray
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half bath
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.5 (34)
"Beachy Keen" is a terrific Nags Head vacation home that provides ample room for your family, lovely décor throughout, Private Saltwater Swimming Pool, Hot Tub, Rec. Room w/Foosball & Den w/TV. Ideally situated, this home offers direct access to the Beach (approximately 175 yards to Hollowell Street beach access or just 4 houses from Ocean) in
427 | Beachy Keen
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.2 (44)
Situated between the Atlantic Ocean and Jockey's Ridge in upscale Old Nags Head Place, this terrific vacation home has something to offer for all. A spacious, well-appointed interior, Private Swimming Pool, Hot Tub, and Rec. Room provide comfort in a relaxing environment for your family. Centrally located in Nags Head, this home is convenient to ar
883 | Old Nags Head Place
Home Pet Friendly
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.5
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.5 (6)
Island Delight is an exceptional vacation home that provides a wide array of amenities all designed with your vacation needs in mind. The décor throughout is lovely and special attention has been paid to the exterior areas of the property including the fencing of the entire back yard which encompasses your own Private Swimming Pool, Hot Tub, Volley
263 | Island Delight
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 6 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half bath
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Saturday
Rating 4.5 (24)
Updates for the 2025 season include: All new dining room furniture, new artwork throughout and 5 of the six baths have been renovated. This is a wonderful home with great location, inviting exterior areas and a location that is within easy walking distance of the beach! Mostaccioli Nights is an outstanding vacation home situated in close proximity
440 | Mostaccioli Nights
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.8
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.5 (27)
Great location, special touches throughout the home will add to your delight and convenience. This Outstanding Home is located in "Old Nags Head Place", one of Nags Heads finest developments, and offers 3 Luxurious living levels for your vacation enjoyment. Exceptional in both Design and Décor this home offers a high level of Amenities along w/many
406 | Three Palms
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half Bathrooms 2 half baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.8
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.6 (33)
Knot at Work is a terrific vacation home that features lovely décor throughout, spacious floor plan, and comfortable furnishings your family is sure to enjoy. Ideally situated in "Old Nags Head Place" with easy walking to both the Bainbridge Street and Curlew Street Beach Accesses (each approximately 350 yards). Knot at Work is centrally located t
Specials Tag View Special
340 | Knot At Work
Weekly Specials

5/17/26 to 5/23/26 - Reduced from $2,195.00 to $1,895.00

5/31/26 to 6/6/26 - Reduced from $3,495.00 to $3,195.00

340 | Knot At Work
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 11.5
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.6 (11)
Experience the best of the Outer Banks at this beautiful home located in Old Nags Head Place. This home has been designed for comfort, fun, and has all the extras to make your vacation special including outstanding design, lovely decor, and nothing has been overlooked. Wake up to a sunrise over the Atlantic and take a short stroll down to the Beach
Specials Tag View Special
648 | Sunny Side Up
Weekly Specials

5/31/26 to 6/6/26 - Reduced from $3,995.00 to $3,495.00

648 | Sunny Side Up
Home
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half bath
Location Oceanside
Town Nags Head
Milepost Milepost 12
Checkin day Sunday
Rating 4.9 (29)

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree